Stop-Loss Costs a Small Employer 10 Times More Per Head. That's Why Most Stay Insured.

https://www.axiomaticdata.com/blogPosts/stop-loss-costs-a-small-employer-10-times-more-per-head-thats-why-most-stay-insured

New self-funded health plan data from Form 5500: a 100–249 participant company pays a median $215 per participant per month for stop-loss, a 5,000+ company $20. Self-funding climbs from 39% to 94% with size, and in 2025 more than twice as many employers moved to self-funding as left it.

We just added self-funded health plan data to Axiomatic Data: every Form 5500 health plan filing for plan years 2022 to 2025, with each employer's funding arrangement, stop-loss carrier, stop-loss premium, administrator and broker.

Here is one thing it shows.

Stop-loss costs ten times more per head at a small company

An employer that self-funds its medical plan pays claims out of its own pocket instead of paying premiums to an insurer. To cap the risk of a very large claim, most buy stop-loss insurance, which reimburses claims above a set amount.

What that protection costs depends heavily on size. A company with 100 to 249 participants pays a median of $215 per participant per month for stop-loss. A company with 5,000 or more pays $20: about a tenth as much per head.

Plan participants Median stop-loss premium, per participant per month
100–249 $215
250–499 $158
500–999 $108
1,000–4,999 $67
5,000+ $20

This follows from how the risk works. A large employer spreads its large claims over thousands of people, so a single cancer case or premature birth barely moves its costs. For a small employer, one large claim can be a meaningful share of the year's spending, and the stop-loss carrier prices that in.

Why it matters: self-funding climbs with size

The cost of stop-loss explains a pattern that is rarely laid out side by side. The share of employers that self-fund their medical plan rises steadily with size:

Plan participants Share of employers that self-fund
100–249 39%
250–499 52%
500–999 68%
1,000–4,999 84%
5,000+ 94%

Below about 250 participants, most employers stay fully insured. Above 1,000, almost all self-fund. The Department of Labor's own count of health plans shows the same climb, from 30% of the smallest large plans to 91% of the largest (2023).

The market keeps moving one way

The direction of travel is clear. In 2025, 1,587 insured employers switched to self-funding, and 719 went the other way: more than two moves into self-funding for every move out.

For anyone selling to employers in the middle bands, that turnover is the opportunity. A company that has just started self-funding is choosing a stop-loss carrier, an administrator and often a new broker for the first time. One that has moved back to an insured plan has likely just run the numbers on its stop-loss renewal.

What the data covers

The Form 5500 is the annual report employee benefit plans file with the Department of Labor. Health plans with 100 or more participants file one, and the schedules attached to it show how the plan is funded and which insurance contracts it holds, including stop-loss policies, their carriers, premiums and the brokers paid on them.

For each employer, Axiomatic Data now shows:

  • whether the medical plan is self-funded or insured, by year
  • the stop-loss carrier and premium
  • the administrator
  • the broker

Ask us for your cut

Want these numbers for your state, industry or size band? Email info@axiomaticdata.com.

Source: U.S. Department of Labor Form 5500 health plan filings, calendar-year plans with 100+ participants, received through October 24, 2026. Stop-loss: median of 2,158 single-employer plans with one stop-loss contract covering at least half the plan. Analysis: Axiomatic Data.